Showing posts with label deepa mehta. Show all posts
Showing posts with label deepa mehta. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 3, 2007

The trial of fire.

The Movie: Fire, directed by Deepa Mehta
Recommendation: Me!
Reason: Deepa Mehta's a good director with a good feel for characters.

To understand the title, here's a snippet of the tale it comes from. Mehta's a little heavy on the metaphor in this movie, bringing up the idea of a trial by fire not once, not twice, but three times (and possibly more, those are just the ones I counted). And that's not including the literal one. As usual, she has written interesting, compelling characters for a very good cast. As a director, she's a 'recycler'-the stars of her movies cross over from one to the next.

Nandita Das wasn't as good in Earth as she was in Fire. I suppose her role was a little meatier here, with more room to really display her talent. She's sweet and interesting here, without any significant failings. Though the script is occasionally thin (and repetetive), she's quite solid. Likewise, Shabana Azmi did an excellent job in her role.

This is Deepa Mehta's earliest film, and it's nice to appreciate her growth as a writer and a director. She takes a fairly biased view of men in her first couple of works. Their characters come off as thin and hollow, especially here in Fire. It's an early-career sort of mistake-I look forward to seeing Water to see how far she's come.

-84/365 down, 281/365 to go

Saturday, March 31, 2007

Can a country be broken?

The Movie: Earth, directed by Deepa Mehta
Recommendation: Me.
Reason: I've been interested in Deepa Mehta's work after seeing a few interviews with her.

I watched Earth over the course of days. It's a heavy movie, though the reason I watched it over a long period had less to do with that and more to do with time constraints. Deepa Mehta's work about the end of British rule in India and the trouble it caused was impactful as well as educational. I don't think we covered much Indian history.

Deepa Mehta wove mutiple levels of metaphor and perspective into this film. Shanta, the woman at the center of a religiously divided group of friends, is both a metaphor for the soon-to-be divided India and the representative of the voices of moderation that surely sounded during the division. Likewise, her friends represent the Sikh, Muslim and Hindu perspectives. Mehta adds another dimension, however, with Lenny-baby to present the perspective of the young, and the older Sethna's to represent the perspectives of the older generation. She gives all of these voices time to speak their piece, in amidst the rapidly devolving situation.

It is an interesting piece of history that Deepa Mehta has presented in her film. I find I appreciate her writing and directing very much-not many can actually pull it off with such candor and honesty (Shyamalan, goddammit, take note!). If you're a completist, by all means watch this film. It's a good, understated historical fiction.

-79/365 down, 286/365 to go